Planning notebook

Compare contractor quotes on the same scope

Compare what each bidder includes before comparing the total. Known exclusions and allowance shortfalls belong next to the headline price.

Updated · By Renovation Guides

Compare up to three quotes

Add only known amounts on the same scope and tax basis. Blank adjustment fields mean zero for the arithmetic; tick the warning if an excluded item is still unpriced. Your inputs are not uploaded or saved by this tool.

Quote A
Quote B
Quote C

An adjusted total does not score workmanship, qualifications, warranty, contract protection, or schedule. An unpriced exclusion keeps a comparison incomplete.

What goes in each adjustment

InputIncludeAvoid
Known missing scopeAn actual price for necessary work excluded from this bid.Inventing a price for an unresolved item.
Allowance shortfallSelected like-for-like cost minus the allowance already included, if positive.Adding the entire selection cost a second time.
Additional tax or feesKnown amounts omitted from the quoted total.Adding tax again when the total already includes it.

A lower bid with a larger adjusted total

Worked example · hypothetical figures

Quote A is USD 18,500 plus USD 1,500 of missing scope, USD 2,000 of allowance shortfall, and USD 500 of known fees: USD 22,500. Quote B is USD 21,800 with those same items included. Quote C is USD 20,200 plus USD 500, but still has an unpriced exclusion. C’s USD 20,700 is incomplete, so the arithmetic cannot identify a winner.

Normalize the scope before trusting the result

Use the same brief and revision date for every bidder. Check quantities, material specifications, installation, removal, protection, disposal, and tax treatment. If a quote is missing a price, ask for clarification rather than using a guessed adjustment to make the comparison look finished.

Check the contract as well as the price

Review contractor qualifications, references, insurance, schedule, payment milestones, warranty, and the change process. The FTC source below provides consumer guidance on choosing a contractor. A worksheet is an arithmetic aid, not a contractor recommendation.

Sources and the limits of these examples

The links below support the consumer-protection or safety context. They are not sources for the example prices. All example amounts on this page are invented to show the arithmetic, in the stated currency; they are not market averages.